NYC Journalists Lose Access to NYPD Radio: A Blow to Breaking News Coverage

A critical NYPD radio frequency went dark on January 15th, 2024, hindering journalists' ability to cover breaking news in real-time. This is the latest stage in the NYPD's ongoing radio encryption efforts, which began in July 2023. The encrypted frequency, known as “Special Operations Division,” provided vital information to numerous media organizations.

<img src="https://www.amny.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Screenshot_20220927_180056.jpg" alt="Oliya Scootercaster of Freedom News TV on the job in New York City wearing her press ID.">

The NYPD claims encryption is necessary to prevent criminals from accessing police communications. However, journalists have used police radios for over 90 years to report breaking news without incident. The NYPD's statement claims that “no, radios are not provided to some news organizations and not others,” and offers no concrete solution for reporters' access.

Impact on News Gathering

The encryption significantly impacts newsgathering, particularly for freelance journalists who rely on police radio for breaking news alerts. The lack of access means delayed reporting and a potential decrease in public awareness of crimes.

"I don’t even know what to say at this point – we knew this was coming, and what now, nobody will report on crime,” said Oliya Scootercaster, owner of Freedom News Service.

The Highway Patrol radio frequency is also expected to be encrypted soon, further limiting access to real-time information on traffic incidents. Three citywide channels will remain unencrypted, but their usefulness to the press remains unclear.

Legislative Action and Public Response

A bill, the “Keep Police Radio Public Act,” aims to prevent the NYPD from blocking press access to police radio. While it passed the State Senate last June, it didn't pass the Assembly. Assemblymember Karines Reyes plans to reintroduce the bill. The City Council is also considering solutions to address the issue.

The NYPD's encryption also affects volunteer EMS and private ambulance groups, hindering their response to medical emergencies. This contradicts federal mandates for interoperability between first responders established after 9/11.

Concerns and Criticisms

News organizations, journalists, and even former NYPD officers express strong concerns about the lack of transparency and its impact on public safety and trust. They emphasize that the encrypted system poses a significant challenge to their ability to inform the public effectively.

The situation raises important questions about transparency, public safety, and the role of the media in a democratic society.