NYC's Composting Law Sparks Landlord Backlash

Starting April 1st, NYC is cracking down on composting violations, and landlords aren't happy. The citywide composting program, launched last October, requires separating food scraps and soiled paper. But landlords argue they can't enforce the rules on tenants and will be unfairly fined for their tenants' non-compliance.

The Controversy

The new rules mandate that food scraps and soiled paper must be composted, with fines ranging from $25 to $100 for buildings with up to 8 units, and $100 to $300 for larger buildings. Landlords like Christopher Athineos, who manages 100 units in Brooklyn, express concerns about the practicality and safety of enforcing the law:

"It’s nasty stuff, and it’s hazardous. Why should property owners, porters, building owners, superintendents have to expose themselves to this?"

Kenny Burgos of the New York Apartment Association adds:

"The law essentially amounts to supers having to dumpster dive through trash... It’s a law that is going to be incredibly difficult to comply with."

The Department of Sanitation, however, maintains that composting is essential for diverting waste from landfills, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and preventing rat infestations, comparing it to the established practice of recycling.

Financial Impact

The financial burden on landlords is a significant concern. Fines can quickly escalate, especially for larger buildings, potentially impacting their bottom lines and tenant relations. The lack of clear enforcement mechanisms for landlords makes the situation even more frustrating.

Looking Ahead

This new composting law is creating a significant clash between the city's environmental goals and the practical challenges faced by property owners. The coming months will likely reveal the full impact of this initiative and whether adjustments will be needed to balance environmental concerns with the realities of building management.