Brooklyn Monsignor Fired Amid $1.9M Fund Mishandling Scandal

Monsignor Jamie Gigantiello of Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, has been relieved of his duties following an investigation into the mishandling of church funds and the use of a church credit card for personal expenses. The Diocese of Brooklyn announced the decision after uncovering serious financial violations during ongoing legal investigations related to a federal corruption scandal.

Key Findings of the Investigation:

• $1.9 Million in Transfers: Gigantiello allegedly transferred approximately $1.9 million in parish funds to bank accounts associated with Frank Carone's law firm and affiliated companies. These transfers were presented as loans or business investments, some with interest, others without.
• Unauthorized Credit Card Use: The investigation also revealed the use of a church credit card for substantial personal expenses, which are still under investigation. While Gigantiello's attorney claims the credit card use was authorized, the Diocese disputes this claim.
• Sabrina Carpenter Music Video Controversy: The scandal followed an earlier incident where Gigantiello allowed the filming of a Sabrina Carpenter music video at the church, violating diocesan policy. This action resulted in his immediate loss of status.
• Interference with Administration: The Monsignor also interfered with the administration of the parish after being directed not to do so.

The Aftermath:

Gigantiello's replacement, Deacon Dobbins, has also been placed on administrative leave following the discovery of a recording made by Gigantiello of a private conversation where Dobbins used offensive and racist language.

The investigation was initiated by Bishop Robert Brennan as part of a broader assessment of compliance with diocesan policies at Our Lady of Mount Carmel.

A spokesperson for Carone's law firm stated that the business deals with the church resulted in a financial benefit for the diocese. However, Gigantiello failed to obtain necessary approvals for the transactions.

Neither Gigantiello, Carone, nor Dobbins have been charged with any crimes at this time. The investigation is ongoing.